Rumors of classic muscle car values dropping are both true and false at the same time, depending on the model and engine. Primo rides like big-block Mustangs, Hemi-equipped anythings, and Mopars in general are still rocking and rolling, but there are some that are sinking rather dramatically. We took a look at the Hagerty good condition values of classic muscle cars over the past five years and found a few that are almost in a price nose-dive. This, however, is a temporary state of decline, and there will be a market correction that puts these desirable vehicles back into an upward trajectory, so now is a perfect time to act on a rare deal for a soon-to-be unattainable Golden Age gem.
As noted, Mopar is still running strong, but curiously, the 1968 Plymouth Road Runner base with a 335-horsepower 383 Magnum V8 is falling out of favor with collectors. With over a 15% drop in value in the previous half-decade, the OG budget street machine is once again a bargain bruiser. Five years ago, a good condition ’68 was worth $40,100 but is now down to $34,000; either figure is a solid price for a classic Mopar, but the drop doesn’t make a lot of sense. The Road Runner didn’t suddenly become uncool and there hasn’t been a flood of them up for auction, making for a buyer-friendly supply and demand situation. While the ’68 Road Runner was successful in its debut year, there were only around 43,000 of them made, which is far below the production numbers of Ford and GM muscle cars, so this should be a vehicle that never loses value. This minor setback is temporary, so this is one that collectors should act on while it remains inexplicably undervalued.
Every car on this list is going to seem baffling to muscle car enthusiasts, but perhaps none so much as the 1968 Chevy Camaro SS 396, which is down over 26% in the last five years. This is the car that Bowtie fans want the most and yet it’s lost nearly $20,000 in value. This price drop is for the ’68 Camaro SS 396 with 325 hp L35 V8, which is slightly less desirable, but even the 375 hp L89 is down 16%, which is a head-scratcher in and of itself. For the purposes of this piece, we chose the Hagerty good condition value because that’s generally how most classics are sold. Excellent condition is an extensive restoration, while good condition is a nearly perfect ride that only nitpicky car show judges could find flaws with. Regardless of condition, the ’68 Camaro SS 396 is down in value across the board, and at a $54,400 average price, it represents an outstanding deal.
The 1970 Buick GS 455 has always been an underappreciated and undervalued Golden Age street beast, but recently it is practically falling off the map. The all-time high value was $36,000, which many would consider low for a 13-second classic muscle car, but that figure has since dropped to $26,200. This, of course, is for the base 350 hp, 510 lb-ft of torque version, but the 360 hp GS 455 Stage One is also declining, with an even more dramatic 34.4% drop in value. Even the special-edition 1970 GSX, with a Stage 1 455 has gone from $152,000 collectible to a $105,000 bargain-basement classic. Sooner or later, collectors are going to realize how seriously impressive the ’70 GS 455 really is, and prices are going to climb, but as it stands now, there is no better deal on one of the few GM muscle cars that could actually compete with the top Mopar street machines.
This is another one that the Bowtie Brigade is going to have trouble wrapping their heads around, because it’s downright shameful. The ’65 Chevy Chevelle Malibu SS 327’s value has sunk by over 30% over the previous five years, with no logical explanation. The 250 hp 327 L30 SS has gone from $39,100 to just $27,300 and, granted, this isn’t the top engine option for a ’65 Chevelle, but it’s still a genuinely compelling classic that shouldn’t be losing value. This isn’t a fluke as the 350 horsepower L79 version of the 327 is also down nearly 20%. The one exception, and yet somehow the most striking contrast, is that the ultra-rare 1965 Chevelle SS 396 Z16 is climbing in value, up 27.6% with a good condition value of $125,000. For enthusiasts who don’t want to pay six figures for early Chevy muscle, it’s hard to find a better deal than a ’65 Chevelle SS 327, and because it’s not a six-figure show car, buyers can actually drive and enjoy it.
This plummeting Pontiac stings the most for classic fans because the GTO was the ride that set off the muscle car craze in 1964. As surprising as it seems, a ’66 GTO has lost over 35% of its value recently, which would indicate that collectors are losing interest in the originator of the muscle car era. 1966 was the final year for the iconic 389 Tri-Power V8 with its triple two-barrel carburetor setup, which produced up to 360 hp that year. This is the most desirable first-generation GTO and should be climbing in value, instead of sinking. Upon closer review, the GTO is now the Greatest Value Of All Time. The ’64 GTO is down 21.8%, and the ’65 has dropped by 20.6%. But hey, picking up a solid ’66 for around $50,000 doesn’t exactly suck. While some pristine ’65 GTOs have sold for over $100,000, acquiring one for half that price is entirely achievable, as dozens have sold at auction for that figure or less.
No Comments