Dream cars have a way of staying just out of reach. Whether it’s the intoxicating wail of a Ferrari V8 or the effortless authority of a Porsche 911 Turbo, the cars that dominate our screensavers tend to dominate our budgets too. But the used market is full of hidden gems — genuinely fast, genuinely exciting machines that deliver a serious slice of that supercar experience without the supercar price tag. If you know where to look, you can drive something extraordinary for a fraction of what the headline names command. sports cars The sporty offerings from brands such as Ferrari and Porsche are some of the best in the world. Sadly, they’re also often some of the most expensive, even if you buy them used. However, there are plenty of alternatives out there that can give you the same kind of power and performance for a lot less money.
The cars on this list come from a variety of different brands and different eras. Most of them are modern cars, but there is one classic thrown in the mix as well. Some offer a more old-school experience than enthusiasts might prefer over newer models. Mostly, though, these are simply much cheaper alternatives to very expensive cars that most people won’t be able to afford.
For this list, HotCars looked at cheaper alternatives to cars that are expensive or rapidly appreciating in value. We used classic.com to find the values of those cheaper alternatives.
|
Engine |
3.8-liter twin-turbocharged V6 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed automatic |
|
Power |
473-562 hp |
|
Torque |
430-467 lb-ft |
Source: Nissan
If you want a high-performance car with a twin-turbo six-cylinder — something like the blisteringly fast 911 Turbo S or even a Maserati MC20 — but don’t want to pay supercar money, there is a genuine alternative. That alternative is one of the most beloved sports cars on the planet: the R35 Nissan GT-R. It’s a technological marvel, delivering up to 562 hp from the factory along with a comprehensive suite of electronic driver aids. These cars also respond exceptionally well to tuning, with power figures of 600 or even 800 hp well within reach.
The R35 Nissan GT-R has been discontinued. But there are still plenty of examples on the used market, and they’re a lot cheaper than any Porsche 911 or Maserati MC20. The average used value of an R35 GT-R is around $96,354. But there are plenty of examples that have sold for considerably less — quite a few used GT-Rs have changed hands for between $40,000 and $50,000, and some have even sold for under $37,000. Given the R35’s performance credentials, that’s extraordinary value.
|
Engine |
1.7-liter turbocharged inline-4 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed automatic |
|
Power |
237 hp |
|
Torque |
258 lb-ft |
Source: Alfa Romeo
The Ferrari 458 has to be one of the best cars ever to wear the prancing horse badge. While it was the first Ferrari to not have a manual transmission option, it’s still remembered as a high-water mark in Ferrari’s ability to build fantastic road cars. Used 458s share the same problem that all Ferraris do, though — they’re priced well out of reach for most of us. There is, however, a fantastic Italian sports car alternative at a fraction of the cost: the Alfa Romeo 4C. Available in both coupe and spider versions, the 4C is a featherlight sports car built around a racing car-style carbon fiber tub. It may only have a 1.7-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, but thanks to the 4C’s minimal weight, its 237 hp is more than enough to deliver genuinely exciting performance.
Sadly, the Alfa Romeo 4C is mainly remembered as a commercial flop. It’s not the cheapest car on this list either, with prices ranging from around $54,532 for a coupe to $70,857 for a Spider. But that’s still a lot cheaper than a Ferrari 458, and in many ways it’s just as fun to drive.
|
Engine |
5.0-liter supercharged V8 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed manual, 8-speed automatic |
|
Power |
542 hp |
|
Torque |
502 lb-ft |
Source: Jaguar
The Aston Martin Vantage is one of the best-looking and most capable sports cars you can buy right now. It has that distinctly British charm only an Aston Martin can deliver, and its AMG-derived V8 is absolutely glorious. But if you want a V8-powered British sports car without the Aston Martin price, there are alternatives. One of the most compelling is the first-generation Jaguar F-Type R. Packing a 5.0-liter supercharged V8 that produces 542 hp and 502 lb-ft of torque, it has enough firepower to run with some seriously quick performance cars — and it backs that up with an incredible V8 soundtrack that rivals the Aston Martin Vantage’s.
A first-generation Jaguar F-Type R will cost you around $47,204 on the used market. That’s a remarkable bargain for a proper sports car from a prestigious manufacturer with a supercharged V8 under the hood.
|
Engine |
7.0-liter V8 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed manual |
|
Power |
505 hp |
|
Torque |
470 lb-ft |
Source: Chevrolet
The C8-generation Chevrolet Corvette Z06 is easily one of the best Corvette models ever made. It puts out 670 hp and 460 lb-ft of torque from its 5.5-liter flat-plane V8, delivering tremendous performance and a glorious soundtrack. Its mid-engine layout also provides far better weight distribution and sharper handling than the front-engine cars it replaced. But these cars are extremely expensive, even on the used market. Thankfully, older Z06 generations offer similarly brilliant performance at a much lower cost. The generation to go for is the C6.
The C6 Z06 also has a naturally aspirated V8, but it’s an entirely different beast from the flat-plane unit in the C8. Instead, it’s a massive 7.0-liter engine producing 505 hp — less than the C8’s 670, but with slightly more torque at 470 lb-ft versus 460. More importantly, it’s a legitimate big-block engine in a modern sports car. You can’t get much more “there’s no replacement for displacement” than that.
A C6 Corvette Z06 will cost you around $47,100 on the used market, with some examples selling for under $27,000. While that’s not cheap in absolute terms, it’s a significant saving over the C8 Z06 — especially when you factor in the dealer markups that have plagued new Z06 sales. You might even prefer the older car, as some enthusiasts argue it delivers a better driving experience than the C8.
|
Engine |
5.9-liter V12 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed manual, 6-speed automatic |
|
Power |
450 hp |
|
Torque |
420 lb-ft |
Source: Aston Martin
The Aston Martin DB12 is the pinnacle of what the classic British marque can achieve when building a grand tourer for the modern era. It’s fast, beautiful, comfortable, and powered by a strong AMG-derived V8 engine. That engine is a bit of a sticking point, though. There was once a time when a V12 was practically standard issue for Aston Martin grand tourers. For those who want that old-school V12 experience, the DB12’s cheaper alternative delivers exactly that. The Aston Martin DB9 is an ancestor of the DB12 and one of the most celebrated Astons of all time. The first-generation VH I version’s gorgeous Ian Callum-penned lines have barely aged a day. It’s comfortable enough to cross continents in ease, and it’s powered by a magnificent 5.9-liter V12 that sounds like nothing else on the road.
How much you pay for a DB9 depends on the specification you choose. Whatever version you pick, though, it’s considerably cheaper than a new DB12. Automatic coupes are the most affordable, going for around $40,183. The most expensive are manual Volante convertibles, which are worth around $67,427. While that’s already a fantastic deal, the DB9 is heading straight toward future classic status — meaning these prices won’t stay low for long. If you want one, the window may be closing.
|
Engine |
4.7-liter V8 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed automated manual |
|
Power |
434 hp |
|
Torque |
361 lb-ft |
Source: Maserati
There aren’t many sports cars as important or influential as the Porsche 911. It’s been the benchmark for what a sports car should be for as long as it has existed. But many versions of the 911 are incredibly expensive, which has created a healthy market for cheaper alternatives. Perhaps one of the best of them is the Maserati GranTurismo S. Sold from 2008 to 2011, the GranTurismo S leans more toward grand tourer than outright sports car. But that doesn’t mean it lacks serious power. The GranTurismo S shared its 4.7-liter V8 with the Alfa Romeo 8C, producing 434 hp and 361 lb-ft of torque — figures that put it on a par with several Porsche 911 variants of the same era.
A Maserati GranTurismo S can be had for around $34,260 today. That’s an absolute bargain for a proper V8 sports car — in fact, it’s arguably one of the biggest bargains anywhere in the used market right now.
|
2006-2008 |
2009-2014 |
|
|
Engine |
4.2-liter supercharged V8 |
5.0-liter supercharged V8 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed automatic |
6-speed automatic |
|
Power |
410 hp |
503 hp |
|
Torque |
413 lb-ft |
461 lb-ft |
Source: Jaguar
The first-generation Jaguar F-Type R isn’t the only supercharged V8 Jaguar that makes a compelling alternative to the Aston Martin Vantage. Its predecessor, the second-generation Jaguar XKR, fits that bill just as well. It’s more of a grand tourer than the F-Type R, but it still delivers serious performance. Originally fitted with a 4.2-liter supercharged V8 producing 410 hp and 413 lb-ft of torque, it received a significant upgrade in 2009 when Jaguar swapped in the 5.0-liter supercharged V8 that would later power the F-Type R — adding nearly 100 hp and around 50 lb-ft of torque in the process.
The second-generation Jaguar XKR is now one of the biggest performance bargains on the market. You can pick one up for around $28,803 — incredible value for one of the last proper V8 Jaguars, and a fraction of what an Aston Martin Vantage commands.
|
Engine |
3.2-liter inline-6 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed manual, 6-speed automated manual |
|
Power |
338 hp |
|
Torque |
269 lb-ft |
Source: BMW
The current BMW M4 is a genuinely capable car. But it carries an image problem that won’t go away: that oversized grille remains a polarizing design choice, and some enthusiasts aren’t sold on its twin-turbocharged inline-six either. For those craving a BMW M-car with a more old-school character, there’s a legendary alternative available for far less money — the E46 generation BMW M3. The E46 M3 remains beloved by enthusiasts, and rightly so. It was the last M-car to use a naturally aspirated inline-six, its styling is far easier on the eyes than the G82 M4’s, it has a solid reputation for reliability, and it’s a tuner’s dream.
E46 M3 prices vary depending on body style and transmission. The most affordable examples are SMG-equipped convertibles, worth around $22,189 according to Classic.com. The most sought-after regular models are manual coupes, which go for around $33,349. Special variants like the M3 CSL command significantly more, and don’t qualify as the budget alternative we’re looking for here.
|
1st Generation |
2nd Generation |
|
|
Engine |
2.0-liter flat-4 |
2.4-liter flat-4 |
|
Transmission |
6-speed manual, 6-speed automatic |
6-speed manual, 6-speed automatic |
|
Power |
197-204 hp |
228-232 hp |
|
Torque |
151 lb-ft |
184 lb-ft |
Source: Subaru
The Porsche 718 Cayman is one of the finest small sports cars money can buy. It has great performance, exceptional handling, and the prestige that comes with the Porsche badge. But it’s also an expensive proposition, even used. Thankfully, there are solid cheaper alternatives, and one of the best is the Subaru BRZ. The sibling of the Toyota GT86/GR86, the BRZ applies the classic sports car recipe — light weight, rear-wheel drive, balanced chassis — and executes it to near perfection. Power from the factory isn’t overwhelming, but the BRZ’s relatively light curb weight means every horsepower is put to good use. It’s also highly tunable, meaning a well-built BRZ could realistically match a 718 Cayman’s pace at a fraction of the cost.
Used BRZs can be found for around $20,997, with early examples occasionally selling for as little as $11,000. At those prices, it’s easy to see why so many enthusiasts have chosen a BRZ over pricier alternatives.
|
AW10 |
AW11 |
|
|
Engine |
1.5-liter inline-4 |
1.6-liter inline-4, 1.6-liter supercharged inline-4 |
|
Transmission |
5-speed manual, 4-speed automatic |
5-speed manual, 4-speed automatic |
|
Power |
82 hp |
112-128 hp (1.6-liter inline-4), 145 hp (1.6-liter supercharged inline-4) |
|
Torque |
87 lb-ft |
97-109 lb-ft (1.6-liter inline-4), 140 lb-ft (1.6-liter supercharged inline-4) |
Source: Toyota
The Lotus Elise is one of the purest expressions of what a sports car can be — light, focused, and thoroughly analog. Unfortunately, first-generation examples are becoming expensive, driven by their well-established path toward proper classic status and the kind of unfiltered driving experience that modern sports cars simply can’t replicate. But you can get something with a very similar feel for far less money: the first-generation Toyota MR2. Introduced in the 1980s, the W10 MR2 was designed from the outset to be a fun and affordable sports car. Toyota’s engineers drew heavily from the parts bin of the era while adhering to Colin Chapman’s philosophy of “simplify and add lightness.” The result is a car that’s not only entertaining to drive — thanks to its lightweight construction and mid-engine layout — but also cheap to run and easy to maintain.
A W10 Toyota MR2 can be found for anywhere from around $10,114 to around $20,749, depending on the version. The supercharged variant commands the higher end of that range. Even so, that’s still less than you’d expect to pay for a first-generation Lotus Elise in good condition.
Sources: classic.com.
No Comments