The Hyundai Tucson Years Worth Buying And The Ones To Avoid
Perhaps it is the Tucson that propelled Hyundai to mainstream popularity, especially when it debuted in 2005. With compact crossovers already becoming popular at the time, the Tucson became an affordable alternative to its Japanese and American rivals. Hyundai at the time was also at a stage where it had a lot to prove, and so it did its best to make the Tucson a highly regarded crossover SUV in terms of reliability.
And indeed it was. The first-generation model was an immediate sales success, and part of that was driven by Hyundai winning accolades for its quality and reliability, including for the Tucson. It was given the “Highest-Quality All-New Model” recognition from J.D. Power upon its debut in 2005.
This brings us to today’s article, in which we’ll discuss which model years of the Hyundai Tucson are the best and which you should avoid if you’re looking to purchase a used model. To make this list more informative, we’ll rank the best and worst generations for reliability, as well as determine the best and worst model year of each generation.
Third Generation (2016–2021)
The third-generation Tucson is when Hyundai toned down its Fluidic Sculpture design language into something a bit more restrained. This is also where Hyundai introduced a sportier but more efficient dual-clutch transmission (DCT) option, which led to some interesting developments for this generation. Though still largely reliable, lingering issues make this generation the least reliable of them all.
Best Model Year: 2021
The trend of the final model year of a generation being the overall best in terms of quality and reliability applies in the third-generation Tucson as well. By 2021, the third-generation Tucson had already had its kinks ironed out, as reflected by AutoReliability.Index’s rating of 78 out of 100. The 2021 model year only faced a single recall and a decent 58 complaints, resulting in a rating of Good by the publication.
Top issues for the 2021 model year of the Tucson include the engine, though with 20 issues, they aren’t necessarily widespread. Other issues, present in much smaller numbers, include the service brakes and electrical gremlins. It is also worth noting that since the 2019 facelift, this generation of the Tucson dropped the clunky dual-clutch transmission, potentially improving its overall durability and smoothness.
Worst Model Year: 2017
The 2017 model year is the second year of the third-generation Hyundai Tucson, and though it has fewer overall complaints than the 2016 model year, it is deemed by CarComplaints (which uses the same NHTSA resource for customer complaints as AutoReliability.Index) as the worst model year due to its costly problems. The 2017 model year is also subject to an engine recall specific to the 2.0-liter Nu GDI engines, because these engines suffer premature wear of the connecting rod bearings due to a manufacturing flaw.
Common complaints from this model year also include its rough transmission, though most of them concern the operation of the 1.6-liter turbo four-cylinder’s dual-clutch transmission (DCT) rather than outright transmission failure. Opting for the 2.0-liter Nu GDI engine gave you a smoother six-speed automatic, but buyers looking to purchase a used Tucson with this powertrain should verify that the engine has already been addressed by the recall.
Second Generation (2010–2015)
The second-generation Hyundai Tucson was introduced in the 2010 model year, and it broke the mold for what Hyundai would become known for going forward. No longer a brand you bought simply because it was value-oriented, you now bought a Tucson because of its radically stylish design. Without the DCT, this was largely more reliable than the third-generation model, but it still had its own problems, too.
Best Model Year: 2015
Once again, the best model year for the second-generation Hyundai Tucson is the final model year, which, in this case, is the 2015 model year. By this time, its production kinks had been ironed out, and that’s why J.D. Power gave this model year a reliability score of 86 out of 100. At this point, the Tucson’s issues, such as early oil consumption and electrical glitches that had plagued earlier models, had already been ironed out.
Though the 2015 model year had more overall complaints at CarComplaints than the 2014 model year, the complaints of this model year are a lot more minor, as they are usually centered around vibration and refinement complaints. The 2015 model year also saw an ABS-related recall, which, if unaddressed, can cause a fire within the engine compartment. Though this next one is not necessarily a recall campaign, a Tucson with the 2.0-liter Nu GDI engine for this model year may be eligible for the extended Powertrain Limited Warranty coverage, or a settlement if you paid for repairs for this engine, assuming it is still in factory spec and meets other conditions.
Worst Model Year: 2012
The worst model year for this generation of the Tucson is 2012. Though it has the same number of complaints as the 2011 model year in CarComplaints, the failures of the 2012 model year are costlier, as they include 26 reports of engine failures. Other issues for this model year include more minor ones such as refinement complaints on the transmission, electrical systems, and interior.
The 2012 model year is also subject to an engine oil leak safety risk, in which the engine oil pan may leak, leading to a loss of engine oil and increasing the risk of an engine stall or fire. It must be noted, however, that though the 2.4-liter Theta II MPi engine was available for this generation, the Tucson was never included in the widespread Theta II engine recall. At most, Hyundai has agreed to settlements for eligible Tucson owners who paid for repairs for this engine, as long as it is in factory spec and satisfies other conditions.
First Generation (2005–2009)
This is the pioneering generation of the Hyundai Tucson—the one that started it all. No frills, no drama, pure sensibilities. It’s what a car was destined to do—become a stress-free mode of transportation. Or is it? Well, in 2005, J.D. Power gave it the “Highest-Quality All-New Model” recognition to highlight just that. No DCT, no turbochargers, and no direct injection. Mechanical simplicity made this Tucson generation very reliable.
Best Model Year: 2009
Once again, the best model year for this generation of the Tucson is its final model year. By 2009, the mechanically simple first-generation Tucson already had its minor production kinks fixed. Gone are the minor electrical gremlins, as reflected by its single-digit complaints at CarComplaints. If you check the complaints, most of them are on the minor side, as they are all related to refinement complaints such as vibrations or shakes.
Worst Model Year: 2005
Don’t assume, however, that the first-ever model year of the Hyundai Tucson is unreliable. Perhaps it is, due to sheer age, but while the 2005 model year still suffered from a few production kinks, it never experienced any widespread catastrophic failures or recalls affecting critical vehicle components.
Once again, this is reflected in the concerns logged by CarComplaints: only one owner reported a blown head gasket, while other concerns centered around trim and electrical issues. Overall, with the 2005 model year already coming from a reliable start, it isn’t surprising that all the succeeding model years are also very reliable.
Fourth Generation (2022–2026)
The Hyundai Tucson is now in its fourth generation, and it is widely considered the best generation in every way. It looks stylish and well-built, and it’s one of the most reliable generations overall. Understandably, being a newer model, it will take a while before reliability issues pop up, if there are any, but positive signs are pointing towards this being one of the most reliable generations ever.
Best Model Year: 2026
At this point, it may sound like a broken record, but it’s no surprise that the best model year for the fourth-generation Tucson is once again its final model year. Almost all the production kinks and recalls have been ironed out, and that’s reflected in AutoReliability.Index’s rating for the 2026 model year. It has a rating of 80 out of 100, which is considered excellent, as the 2026 model year only faced four recalls and merely three complaints.
Understandably, being merely a year old, complaints will be few, but as we are already in the fourth quarter of 2026, and a new generation model has been revealed for 2027, it’s safe to analyze how reliable the 2026 model year is at this point. Common complaints center around its lane departure warning and forward collision avoidance, while one complaint concerns its fuel system. Other than that, the 2026 model year is probably the most refined Tucson ever, especially since the generation’s introduction in 2022 already came from a reliable start.
Worst Model Year: 2022
The 2022 model year is the first of the fourth-generation Hyundai Tucson, and as with every first model year following a full redesign, it is typically the one with the most minor issues. To be fair, with a rating of 66 out of 100, it is still rated as Good by AutoReliability.Index, so owning a Tucson from this model year is not necessarily a liability. Though it only had three recalls, this model year received 433 customer complaints, 87 of which are concerning the vehicle’s powertrain.
Overall, the 2022 model year is still adequate from a reliability standpoint, but if you’re in the market for a fourth-generation Tucson, it’s best to look for a different model year. This generation of the Tucson already ditches the problematic Theta II engines of the past, and though early production bugs make the 2022 model year the least desirable for this generation, it is still much more reliable than the generations that it succeeded.
Related posts
Latest Post
No Comments