What A 5-Year-Old Ford Mustang Is Really Worth In 2026

6 minutes reading

Thursday, 27 Aug 2026 14:30 0 2 autotech

Few sports cars have proven as enduring — or as tempting on the used market — as the Ford Mustang. While other legendary nameplates have been retired and options for muscle-car fans continue to shrink, the Mustang soldiers on, and the secondhand market is stacked with well-kept examples at prices that are genuinely hard to argue with.

A Mustang Loses 48 Percent Of Its Value In Five Years

The Ford Mustang is a fantastic sports car for anyone who wants something exciting to drive. Whether you’re buying new or used, it’s worth understanding how much a vehicle you’re investing thousands of dollars in will depreciate over the course of ownership. The Mustang holds its value relatively well and ranks among the best choices if you’re shopping for an affordable performance car.

Depreciation

Actual Cost Of A Used Mustang

Shot of the dashboard, featuring the infotainment system, in a 2019 Ford Mustang

Ford

As noted above, cars rarely sell at their sticker price. The 2021 Mustang’s base MSRP may have been $27,155, but many buyers paid considerably more when it was new. However, KBB reports its fair purchase price to be between $19,850 and $45,100 for the Mach 1. There are plenty of different Mustangs to choose from on the used market, spanning multiple trims, engine options, and the choice between a convertible or a coupe. The most desirable is the GT500, which currently goes for $71,400.

Ford’s Mustang Is Relatively Affordable To Take Care Of

A static top-down rear-quarter shot of a 2021 Ford Shelby Mustang GT500.

One of the most important things to consider when buying a used car — particularly one with a few years on it — is how reliable it is and what it will cost to maintain and repair over the long haul. Fortunately, the Mustang isn’t a money pit in most cases.

The Mustang is generally considered to be a particularly reliable sports car. Obviously, with its many different powertrain options and trim levels, reliability will vary depending on which model you choose. We can, however, draw some conclusions from average owner-reported data.

J.D. Power did not rate the 2021 Mustang, but the 2020 Mustang scored 87 out of 100 for quality and reliability, which collates verified owner information to determine its scores. It is also genuinely difficult to find a negative Mustang review that cites poor reliability.

Maintenance And Repairs

Compared to similar cars, the Mustang isn’t particularly expensive to maintain, at least according to average data. According to CarEdge, the average Mustang costs $7,821 to maintain over its first ten years. RepairPal estimates average annual maintenance spending at $709. Buying the car a few years into its life means you can expect to spend somewhat more than that each year as components age.

You Get A Lot For Your Money With A Mustang

Close up of a blue 2019 Ford Mustang doing a burnout

Ford has always prided itself on delivering strong performance per dollar with the Mustang, and the 2020 model year is no exception. If you want serious horsepower without a serious hit to your wallet, it’s an excellent choice — and beyond the performance figures, it’s also a genuinely pleasant car to live with every day.

Performance

Engine	2.3-Liter Turbocharged Inline-Four	2.3-Liter Turbocharged Inline-Four	5.0-Liter Naturally Aspirated V-8	5.0-Liter Naturally Aspirated V-8
Transmission	6-Speed Manual or 10-Speed Automatic	6-Speed Manual or 10-Speed Automatic	6-Speed Manual or 10-Speed Automatic	6-Speed Manual or 10-Speed Automatic
Horsepower	310 HP	330 HP	460 HP	480 HP
Torque	350 LB-FT	350 LB-FT	420 LB-FT	420 LB-FT
Driveline	RWD	RWD	RWD	RWD

There are four different engines available in the 2020 Mustang lineup. The base engine is the EcoBoost four-cylinder, which offers more punch than its displacement suggests — especially in Performance Package trim, where output climbs to 330 horsepower alongside a unique suspension and handling tune.

Interior And Comfort

The Mustang is a surprisingly comfortable coupe to live with day to day. The interior is well laid out and nods to classic Mustangs with a nostalgic design that remains genuinely functional. The materials on the dashboard aren’t class-leading, but premium touches like heated leather seats and a capable infotainment system make it strong value for money. The one real drawback is rear-seat space: in coupe form, or with the convertible roof raised, back-seat passengers have virtually no headroom, and legroom is equally sparse.

A Used Mustang Is, On Average, Cheaper Than Its Rivals

Front 3/4 shot of a blue 2019 Chevrolet Camaro parked in a studio

The Ford Mustang isn’t your only option if you’re hunting for an affordable used muscle car. The Chevrolet Camaro and the Dodge Challenger are both compelling alternatives — though the main drawback of each is that they tend to cost noticeably more than the Mustang.

Average Used Prices

There are plenty of reasons to consider a Chevrolet Camaro, as long as you steer clear of the base inline-four. Its V-6 and V-8 engine options are excellent, and the performance ceiling is impressively high thanks to the ZL1. The interior is also noticeably more comfortable and feels more modern than the Mustang’s. That said, the Camaro averages $29,898 on the used market — and more once you move past the base engine.

The Dodge Challenger has a couple more caveats worth considering. It comes with a standard V-6 and two V-8 options. The V-6 feels dated, and the 375-horsepower V-8 gets outperformed by its rivals. It’s really only the 485-horsepower V-8 that delivers the kind of excitement you’d expect from the nameplate. The interior is also the weakest of the three, filled with cheap materials throughout. Despite all of this, it is the most expensive of the group by a clear margin, with an average used price of $32,223.